Its always been true that the quarterback position gets more credit (or blame) for winning football games. I’m old enough to remember that Pittsburgh’s Steel Curtain defense crushed *everything* in its sight, notching a couple shutouts during a 9-2 stretch of 1983 when Bradshaw was injured. The unmemorable Cliff Stoudt, who generally carried a clipboard while there, picked up THREE championship rings, starting 16 games, but was a non-factor (244/479/3,217 yds, 14 TDs/28 INTs) beyond handing off to RBs Franco Harris or Rocky Bleier.
Some might recall that Trent Dilfer (career 65-65 record) was the starting quarterback for the Baltimore Ravens in Super Bowl XXXV, but was not re-signed by them, the first starting quarterback to be released after winning a Super Bowl, because everyone knew it was about Super Bowl MVP Ray Lewis and their defense. Teams don’t pay phat free agent $$ for journeyman talent, which will be apparent when the Cowboys don’t pull Ryan Tannehill off his couch after a year despite headlines stating they’ll tap ‘$118M QB’ to finish their season, and probably just suffer with backups Cooper Rush and Trey Lance.
Former Panthers QB Cam Newton seems to finally recognize his career is over, and he probably has a legit bitch about lack of team recognition as ‘one of the greats’ for them. Kuechly, Olsen, Delhomme, Walls, Peppers are in Ring of Excellence, Cam might be soon though. Yes, he was a difference maker, a terror early with his RPO success, but IMHO, he never threw a GO! ball to a streaking receiver, just fastballs that probably contributed to his shoulder problems.
Giving the Carolina Panthers Bryce Young credit for a high-profile second win in a row, their 20-17 overtime victory over the Giants in Germany, its not expected everyone will get crazy happy about Young’s 15/25/126 yds/TD line, but I’m okay with Charlotte fans thinking well about three wins being better than two last season, right?
On the edge of being a Loserville location sports-wise, we can even feel cool about the hometown Hornets (4-7) playing better than half the East. Okay, they’re 8th of 13, only 12-0 Cleveland and 9-2 Celts are over .500. Just sayin’, the young guys are doing better than 2023.
Before flipping the script about a whooole lot of other NFL teams that are truly unhappy with their QBs results, lets point out how chagrined an entire LEAGUE has to be about Caitlin Clark taking her game to Europe https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94eXwTx-xck, where the payoff from her talent will be exponentially higher, with the added benefit of not being thugged on constantly.
Cowboys, Jets, Bears, Browns, Giants
It’s a no-brainer to state these teams are more than just ‘disappointed’ about their status at halfway point of 2024-25 season. The ‘Boys (3-6) ponied up a $60 million per year deal for Dak Prescott just before season opener, and now he’s sidelined with a hamstring injury that’s a lot more serious than what seems like an epidemic of hammies league-wise.
Anyone caught up with that blinding sunlight through the windows on CeeDee Lamb’s non-touchdown non-catch this past week, or Coach McCarthy’s obvious unsigned and won’t be back status after several 12-5 seasons at helm, meh.
The Giants obviously overpaid for Daniel Jones, handing him a 4 yr./$160M deal after a glimmer of ‘better’ in 2022. Instead of picking up a 5th year option for about $22M for his worthwhile production (3205 yds, 15/5 TD/INTs, plus 708 yds/5 TDs rushing) and getting into the playoff at 9-7-1, they served up that whopper contract. While NYG’s 2-8 record is now below the Panthers in standings as worst in NFL, there’s no place to really offload that kind of contract.
Don’t bother surveying the fans about Jones, many of them still don’t think Eli Manning can win a Super Bowl, and he has two rings.
The Jets Aaron Rodgers, who will be in Hall of Fame at some point, turns 41 in December, and suffered an Achilles injury about 15 seconds into last season. On a 3-7 team that seriously thought he was the single ingredient they required to dig out from under a history of negatives to become relevant/Super Bowl contenders, that ain’t gonna happen. There are all kinds of numbers on his guaranteed $$$, but if he taps out after another discouraging year of under-achievement for J-E-T-S! it’s a $66M dead cap hit.
Pass the ‘shrooms please, Aaron.
DeShaun Watson was a terrific player at Clemson, a perhaps less good person with Houston Texans, and the Carolina Panthers should be glad they didn’t overextend themselves during the bidding war (picks and cash) for him that Cleveland Browns ‘won.’ As elusive and productive as Watson was in Texas, over a year and change out of the game over legal troubles, his talents have dissipated completely.
For every previous situation the franchise might want a wish/replay on (1980 MVP Brian Sipe *doesn’t* throw that INT in -37 degree wind chill against Raiders in 1981), the Browns are still in a $92M hole with his contract. They’d probably love to get Joe Flacco back after releasing him end of last year (now 0-3 in Indy), but at 3-7, they are still one of four NFL teams to have never appeared in the Super Bowl (Jaguars, Texans, Lions).
Bears and Fields and Caleb W.
The Bears were lauded for stealing the Carolina Panthers blind by demanding WR DJ Moore to swap draft positions when Panthers wanted their #1 pick in 2023 draft. With the treasure trove of picks from Panthers for privilege of picking Young, it was expected they’d find their own franchise QB, and 2022 Heisman winner Caleb Williams (from USC) joining the Windy City crew would mean everything, the salve to heal all previous wounds. (FYI – McMahon wasn’t that skilled, just a winner with an awesome Bears D of ‘86)
Not so much healing yet, and Bears O-line allowed Williams to be sacked NINE times against the Patriots in recent 19-3 loss, so now 4-5 Bears have ended OC Shane Waldron’s time there, after just nine games. The new guy – Thomas Brown – represents a 7th coordinator in 10 years, the previous guy (Luke Getsy) was hired by Raiders in 2023 and fired in November last year. They’ve gone 23 consecutive possessions without hitting pay dirt, with Williams going 48/95 with zero touchdowns in last three games.
Justin Fields might not have been 100% responsible for his less than successful three seasons in Chicago under those circumstances, but Bears declined to pick up his option for Year 4 based on being ‘just’ an effective runner compared to a multi-talented QB like Lamar Jackson. The Ohio St. product had a couple good games after landing in Pittsburgh, but those who thought Russell Wilson was toast after starting season with a calf injury, Steeler HC Mike Tomlin made him QB1 as soon as Wilson was physically cleared, and Steelers have won three straight.
Patriots, Jaguars, Titans
These aren’t your Tom Brady- Bill Belichick Pats, but they might actually be okay after picking UNC (and Charlotte’s Myers Park grad), Drake Maye at #3 this spring. Maye was ACC Player of the Year in 2022, throwing for 4,321 yds/38 TDs and running for 698 yds/7 TDs. https://www.reddit.com/r/fantasyfootball/comments/1g4dh4s/drake_mayes_nfl_debut_2033_cmp_243_passing_yards/ Its less a question of $$$ as playing time, and he hasn’t blown anything yet.
The Jacksonville Jaguars highly touted (generational talent!) Clemson hero Trevor Lawrence has a 20-34 four-year career record, and signed him for 5 yr/$275M extension in 2024, are 2-8. That’s pretty much all you can say, beyond the Chargers choking a huge lead to them and Jags pulling out a 31-30 Wild Card playoff win as reason for the $275MM.
The Tennessee Titans with – who cares? Ok, they have Will Levis, who’s been sacked 22 times in 148 passing attempts, but the 2023 2nd round pick out of Kentucky (after a couple years sitting at Penn State) has had some productive days, starting with a 238 passing yards/4 TD game in a 28–23 win over the Atlanta Falcons as a rookie. (So it might really be the Titans I don’t care about).
Bottom line for Panther fans, cheer the third win and maybe Bryce’s returning confidence, perhaps even give a nod to fact #MrTeppers$ hasn’t broadcast any negative POVs along the way. By all accounts, he was a solid human being/teammate during his time on the bench, not a distraction like many of the bloated contracts and ‘I deserve better’ attitudes of others.
Being half way to the six wins necessary for payoff from betting against most experts 5.5 win prediction on Panthers season is where I’m at, and their remaining schedule includes two games against Eagles and two against the Buccaneers, so a split with Bucs and Mayfield is probably best shot at $$$. Maybe they can take the Cowboys – Rush or Lance, bring it on! – and just for giggles, ATL because its *always* about beating our division rivals from down on 1-85. That end of regular season loss (15-1) in Super Bowl season still rankles.
A last hmmm…note on QBs
Sam Darnold had three INTs and 0 TDs in last game for Vikings, and nobooody in Charlotte will forget he and Baker Mayfield performed poorly in their short time in the Buckle on the Bible Belt. HC Dave Canales got the Panthers coaching gig because he was a ‘QB Whisperer’ with Mayfield (Tampa Bay) and Geno Smith (Seattle), earning both major contract paydays. Most of the NFL is split on whether Darnold, still only 27, can continue playing well with a tough defense and stacked Vikes receiving corps to get a similar payoff as a free agent elsewhere (Mayfield got $100MM), because rookie JJ McCarthy will almost certainly be given the starters spot in Minnesota when healthy in 2025.
